The University of Arizona


School of Information Resources and Library Science

LiS 524 Information Resource Evaluation
Summer Session II- 1998

Frank Gibbons: Adjunct Professor
Class Time: Monday through Friday 11:00am - 12:45 pm
Psych Room 204

Course Description
This course is an introduction to reference work in all types of libraries/information centers. It covers the evaluation of reference materials in print and electronic formats and the strategies and skills needed to answer questions asked by patrons/clients.

Course Objectives
Students should acquire a knowledge of the principles and methods used in the evaluation of information resources. Students should learn strategies for identifying appropriate information resources to meet the information needs of patrons/clients. Student should become familiar with current trends and issues in reference and information service.

Course Requirements

  1. A short critical evaluation of one printed reference work and one electronic reference source of the same type (eg encyclopedia, dictionary etc) identifying the strengths and weaknesses of each. Comparison is not required.( Due: End of 2nd. Week)
  2. Test(1) based on Information Resource Lists 2 to 6 inclusive.

  3. Compilation of a select bibliography on a specified subject( Due: End of 4th. Week) Students will be invited to use electronic and printed information sources in the compilation of their bibliography and keep a record of their search results for a brief class explanation and discussion.

  4. Test (2) based on topics discussed throughout the course.

    Grading

    1. Information resource evaluation 10%

    2. Test(1) 20%

    3. Bibliography 30%

    4. Test(2) 40%

    Course Outline

    Week 1
    Introduction: the nature of reference work: professional reading
    Types of information resource: evaluation
    Methodology of reference work
    Dictionaries
    Encyclopedias

    Week 2
    Almanacs; Yearbooks; Handbooks
    Directories; Statistics
    Biographical and Geographical reference works
    LIBRARY : practical exercise
    LIBRARY : practical exercise

    Week 3
    TEST 1
    Bibliography: general
    Bibliography: National and Trade
    Bibliography: NUC and other national library catalogs
    LIBRARY: Bibliographical exercises

    Week 4
    Government publications
    Serials
    Indexes and Abstracts
    Evaluation of reference service
    Student presentations and discussions of the Bibliographical Assignment

    Week 5
    Student presentations and discussions of the Bibliographical Assignment
    Student presentations and discussions of the Bibliographical Assignment
    TEST 2
    Overview

    Information Resource Lists

    1. Guides to Reference Material

    Balay, Robert Guide to Reference Books 11th. ed. 1996 Z1035.1 G89
    Walford, A.J Guide to Reference Materials Z1035.1 W33
    American Reference Books Annual(ARBA) Z1035.1 A55
    Reader’s Adviser Z1035 B7

    2. Dictionaries

    Brewer,Annie Dictionaries, Encyclopaedias and Other Word Related Books 4th.ed. 1983 (2 vols) AE5 B73
    Kister, Kenneth Kister’s Best Dictionaries for Adults and Young People: a Comparative Guide 1992 PE1611 K57
    Loughridge,Brendan Which Dictionary? 1990 PE1704 L68

    Webster’s New International 3rd. ed. PE1625 W36
    Random House Dictionary of English Language. Unabridged. PE1625 R3
    American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language PE1625 A53
    Oxford English Dictionary(OED) (in print and on CD) PE1625 O87 1989

    Random House Historical Dictionary of American Slang PE 2846 R36 1994
    Dictionary of American Regional English(DARE) PE2843 D52
    Roget’s International Thesaurus PE1591 R73
    Abbreviations Dictionary PE1693 D4 1995

    3. Encyclopedias

    Kister, Kenneth Kister’s Best Encyclopedias 2nd.ed. 1994 AE1 K57

    Encyclopaedia Britannica AE5 E363
    Encyclopedia Americana AE5 333
    World Book Encyclopedia AE5 W55
    New Columbia Encyclopedia 5th. ed. AG5 C725

    Subject Encyclopedias:-

    New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians ML100 N48
    International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences H40 A215
    Guide to American Law KF156 G772
    Encyclopedia of Religion BL31 E46
    Encyclopedia of Psychology BF31 E52 1994

    4. Almanacs,Yearbooks and Handbooks

    World Almanac AY67 N5 W7(Desk)
    Whitaker’s Almanac AY754 W5(Desk)
    Information Please Almanac AY64 I55

    Annual Register of World Events D2 A7
    Statesman’s Yearbook JA51 S7(Desk)
    Europa Yearbook JNI E85(Desk)
    Municipal Yearbook JS342 A2 I52
    County and City Data Book HA202 A36
    Book of the States JK2403 B6
    New York Public Library Desk Reference 1993 AG6 N49
    Guinness Book of World Records AG243 G87
    Famous First Facts AG5 K315
    Chase’s Calendar of Events D11.5 C48
    Benet’s Reader’s Encyclopedia PN41 B4
    Brewer’s Dictionary of Phrase and Fable PN43 B65
    Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations PN6081 B27
    Oxford Dictionary of Quotations PN6080 O95
    United States Government Manual JK421 A3(Desk)
    Oxford "Companions"series McGraw Hill "Handbooks" series

    5. Directories and Statistics Sources

    Directories in Print AY2001 D57(Desk)
    Encyclopedia of Associations HS17 G332 (Desk)
    Encyclopedia of Business Information Sources HF5353 E9
    Statistics Sources HA36 S84

    Dun and Bradstreet’s Million Dollar Directory HC102 D5(Desk)
    Thomas Register of American Manufacturers HD9720 T6
    Brands and Their Companies T223 V4 A22
    Official Congressional Directory JK1011 A31

    Statistical Abstract of the U.S. HQ202(Desk)
    Historical Statistics of the U.S. HA202 B87
    American Statistical Index(ASI) HA209 A43
    Statistical Reference Index(SRI) HA209 S73

    6. Biographical and Geographical Sources

    Biography and Genealogy Master Index(CD)
    Biography Index Z5381 B5
    Biographical Dictionaries and Related Works 1986 CT104 S66
    Who’s Who in America E663 W56
    International Who’s Who CT120 I5
    Dictionary of American Biography E176 D56
    Dictionary of National Biography DA28 D47
    National Cyclopedia of American Biography E176 N28
    Pseudonyms and Nicknames Dictionary 1982 CT120 P8
    Current Biography CT100 C8
    Newsmaker CT120 C6

    Columbia Lippincott Gazetteer of the World 1962 G103 L7
    Webster’s New Geographical Dictionary G103.5 W42
    Times Atlas of the World G1019 B395
    National Geographic Atlas of the World G1021 N38
    Times Atlas of World History G1030 T54
    Rand McNally Commerical Atlas and Marketing Guide G1200 R36

    7. Bibliographies: General

    Bibliographic Index Z1002 B594
    Gale Directory of Databases QA76.9 D32 D576

    National and Book Trade Bibliography

    Books in Print(Desk) Z1215 P972
    Subject Guide to Books in Print(Desk) Z1215 P973
    Forthcoming Books Z1215 P974
    American Book Publishing Record Z1201 A52
    British National Bibliography Z2001 B75

    National and Union Catalogs

    National Union Catalog. Pre 1956 Imprints. Z881 AI U518
    British Library General Catalogue of Printed Books Z921 B85

    8. Serials

    Ulrich’s International Periodicals Directory( Desk) Z6941 U5
    Serials Directory(EBSCO) (Desk) Z6941 S464
    Gale Directory of Publications and Broadcast Media ( Desk) Z6951 A97
    Magazines for Libraries(Katz) PN4832 M23
    International Directory of Little Magazines and Small Presses Z6944.L5 D5

    9. Indexes and Abstracts

    Play Index PN2021 W48
    Short Story Index PN6010 S3
    Columbia Granger’s Index to Poetry PN1022 H39
    Essay and General Literature Index A13 E752

    Expanded Academic Index(SABIO)
    Reader’s Guide to Periodical Literature A13 R48
    Humanities Index 1974- (Print and CD) A1 3H8
    Public Affairs Information Service Bulletin( Print and CD) Z7163 P9
    Newsbank (CD)
    Dissertation Abstracts OnDisc
    Social Science Citation Index(SSCI) Z7161 S673
    Arts and Humanities Citation Index(AHCI) Z5937 A788
    Alternative Press Index A13 A7
    Popular Periodicals Index A13 P8

    ERIC Educational Resources ( Print, SABIO)
    Psyschological Abstracts 1927- ( Print, CD, SABIO) BFI P65
    Business Periodicals Index HF5001 B72
    America: History and Life E171 A52
    Congressional Information Service Index and Abstracts KF49 C622